Nov
4
2014

How to Replace a Doorbell

How to Replace a Doorbell

By

Recently, while sweeping leaves off the front porch, I noticed my old doorbell ringer was looking pretty sad. After 20+ years it was time to consider replacing it.

old doorbell

I checked out the doorbell ringers at True Value and immediately found one that was perfect for my traditional style home, a Michael Healy brass doorbell ringer in a pretty pineapple design. I fell in love with the pineapple after a visit many years ago to Colonial Williamsburg where I learned the pineapple has long stood as a symbol of hospitality, dating all the way back to the 16th century.

Michael Healy brass Pineapple Doorbell Ringer

I ordered the Michael Healy Pineapple Doorbell Ringer in their polished brass finish to go with my existing doorknocker and doorknob. This doorbell ringer also comes in a nickel and oiled-bronze finish on the True Value site. My ringer arrived quickly, and I couldn't wait to install it!

Before installing my new doorbell ringer, I turned off the power to the existing doorbell per the instructions that came with my new ringer. Removing my old doorbell proved to be a little more involved than I had expected. The screws holding the old ringer onto the molding surrounding the door had rusted and would not loosen up. Fortunately they were sticking out just far enough, I was able to use my Dremel with its metal-cutting wheel to cut the head of the screws off. I wore safety glasses while doing this just in case a tiny sliver of metal flew toward my face.

unattached old doorbell

Once I had the old doorbell ringer loosened from the wall, I once again ran into a rusty screw problem. The screws holding the wires in place would not budge. They were so rusted they just chipped away as I tried to unscrew them.

cut doorbell wires

Since the screws wouldn't budge, I simply cut the old doorbell away.

stripped doorbell wires

Once the old doorbell ringer was removed, I needed to expose the wires again in order to attach the new ringer. I used wire cutters to just barely nick the insulation surrounding the wires. Using my thumbnail, I pulled the insulation away to expose the wires. In the photo below, one wire was done and the nick in the other one is visible in preparation of removing it, too.

You need to be super careful when using wire cutters to cut away the insulation surrounding the wires. Too much pressure and you can easily cut right through your wiring. Since I had limited amount of wire to work with, I didn't want to risk cutting all the way through so I found just barely nicking into the insulation and pulling it away with my thumbnail worked very well.

stripped doorbell wires

Now both wires were exposed and ready for the doorbell ringer.

new doorbell

I loosened the screws on the new doorbell ringer (see white arrow below) in preparation for the install. Be careful that you don't unscrew them too far out. I did that with one of the screws and it took me a while to find it on the floor of the porch because they are so tiny!

While we're looking at this picture below, notice the black plate sticking out here from the pineapple part of the ringer. That is the mounting plate. Some of the Michael Healy doorbell ringers are designed where that plate is removed from the decorative front part of the ringer, in this case-the pineapple.  I briefly attempted to unscrew the hinge screw but it just spun around and around. I didn't want to risk breaking the mechanism so I opted to install the doorknocker as one piece instead of separating the hinge plate.

wired new doorbell

I tucked the wires I had exposed behind each of the two screws and tightened down the screws to make the connection. It doesn't matter which side the wires are attached...they can attach to either side or screw.

installing new doorbell

The doorbell ringer attaches to the molding with just one screw. Fortunately the screw is a good bit bigger than the previous screws, so I was able to use one of the existing screw holes for a snug fit. The screws that come with a Michael Healy doorbell ringer are stainless steel which means there will be no problems with rusty screws down the road.

Since I had left the mounting plate attached to the pineapple, it was a little tricky screwing the mounting screw all the way in. The pineapple would only lift up a short distance so it blocked my efforts to reach the screw with a regular screwdriver.

offset screwdriver

An offset screwdriver came to the rescue! Have you ever used one of these? It worked like a champ! Everyone needs one of these in their tool arsenal because you never know where you're going to need it!

tightening new doorbell

Using the offset screwdriver, I finished tightening the mounting plate against the door frame molding. Unfortunately, the molding around my door isn't flat so I couldn't get a completely flush mount, but it was pretty close. The doorbell ringer didn't wobble even the slightest. It's a nice snug fit.

installed new doorbell

Here's how it looked once installed. So pretty and a definite improvement over the old one!

Because this doorbell ringer was such a nice, big size, it completely covered up the imprint left on the paint by the old ringer. It also has a little built-in light so there's a soft glow surrounding the pineapple once it gets dark. This makes it easy for guests to find the ringer even if the porch lights are off at night.

front entryway with new doorbell

It makes a beautiful statement in all its welcoming, hospitality glory! I love how it looks with my existing brass door knob and door knocker. So much nicer than the old one!

As mentioned before, this particular ringer comes in several finishes. Michael Healy makes so many adorable designs, there's a shell, crab, palm tree dragonfly, frog, fleur-de-lis...too many to list them all here. You can see them all on the True Value website or at your local True Value.

Meet the DIY Blog Squad

We've teamed up with these True Value DIY Blog Squad members to share their home improvement know-how, creativity and experience through helpful DIY tutorials.

  • Image of A House in the Hills

    A House in the Hills

    Sarah is the blogger behind A House in the Hills, a lifestyle blog centered around her love of style, food, decor, travel and dogs.

    View Profile
    View all posts
  • Image of A Night Owl

    A Night Owl

    A creative community featuring DIY/crafts, decor, recipes, family and more for women on the go; whether they are single, stay-at-home or working moms!

    View Profile
    View all posts
  • Image of Between Naps on the Porch

    Between Naps on the Porch

    Passionate about all things DIY - from decorating to gardening.

    View Profile
    View all posts
  • Image of Cleverly Inspired

    Cleverly Inspired

    Be inspired to be clever. Cleverly Inspired shares daily doses of DIY, recipes and crafts all on a budget.

    View Profile
    View all posts
  • Image of Design, Dining + Diapers

    Design, Dining + Diapers

    Design, Dining and Diapers focuses primarily on design, DIY home decor, seasonal crafts, easy recipes and just being a mom.

    View Profile
    View all posts
  • Image of In My Own Style

    In My Own Style

    Enthusiast for all things creative, colorful and DIY.

    View Profile
    View all posts
  • Image of Monica Wants It

    Monica Wants It

    Monica is a DIY blogger living in South Texas who loves to recreate high-end/upscale decor with the tiniest budget possible.

    View Profile
    View all posts
  • Use Energy-Efficient Light Bulbs

    Use Energy-Efficient Light Bulbs

    Let's shed some light on the different styles of energy-efficient bulbs.

    Learn More

  • Fire Prevention Tips

    Fire Prevention Tips

    Get some home fire prevention tips to give you and your family peace of mind.

    Learn How

  • Ladder Safety Tips

    ladder safety Tips

    Before climbing a ladder, be sure you know how to properly use one.

    Learn how

  • Halloween Safety Tips

    Halloween Safety Tips

    Here are some Halloween safety ideas to keep the entire family free of unwanted scares.

    Learn More

  • Pinterest

    Follow Us On Pinterest

    ​Visit our Pinterest page for great do-it-yourself project advice and home inspiration.

    Learn more